Originally Posted by
Niall_Quinn
It's over for Messi and it was over a long time ago for Ronaldo, although I'd say he was closer than Messi ever was to being acknowledged as genuine all time elite because he did the business for two clubs in two different countries whereas Messi has been cosseted at a dominant Barcelona his whole career. Frankly the comparisons to Pele were ludicrous anyway, there's a guy who is synonymous with the World Cup and delivering at the pinnacle. Maradona, obviously a genius technically (like Messi) but lots of question marks and baggage there too. Zidane ranks higher than Messi and Ronaldo in my opinion. He's the one who should be spoken of as a challenger to the title of greatest ever, although it's hard to see how Pele will ever be surpassed in terms of achievement.