
Originally Posted by
Slacker
I'm not sure why all the Gibbs negatives. Let's look at the facts. Cole is old and not playing regularly and gets shown up by pace these days. You can't reverse that. Bainesy is a cracking attacking full back with exceptional dead ball skills but can be a bit susceptible when defending, can't any full back though? You're playing in the best league in the World and the man you're marking is going to be capable of getting away from you now and again.
Not sure if people who stick the pages together over Shaw have actually watched him carefully. He's a confidence player whose head goes down quickly and makes the wrong decision - the failed pass, the wrong turn, the frustratingly bad Hollywood ball. Does the fact that he can sometimes get to the byline and whip the ball in mean that trumps these issues? Sure, Arsenal full backs haven't been up to the mark of late in that respect but Gibbs is a few years ahead of Shaw which makes him more consistent, experienced and able to step up the mark in an England shirt. Maybe there's others who are English, but sorry, Shaw and Cole don't deserve to be ahead of Gibbsy.