Koscielny

[Joker]

its a penalty but not a red. dzecko wouldnt have got to the ball first, therefore it isnt denying a clear goalscoring opportunity given chensey would have got there first. however it is a penalty.

Yes he would have got to the ball if Koscielny hadn't wrestled him to the ground. Watch it again.

[GP]

its a penalty but not a red. dzecko wouldnt have got to the ball first, therefore it isnt denying a clear goalscoring opportunity given chensey would have got there first. however it is a penalty.

Fucking hell, it says it all when Ollie is the only one that's right.

[Niall_Quinn]

Nah, our defending cost us this game.

we handed then two goals by being shit at the back. Otherwise we were the better team overall, which is odd because we were pretty shit. City are a joke club, a billion to produce shit like that.

[Ollie the Optimist]

Yes he would have got to the ball if Koscielny hadn't wrestled him to the ground. Watch it again.

i have. chesney would have got there first. penalty yes, red card no,

[Özim]

It wasn't an obvious red card.

I just don't get how you can say that, he hauled him down in the penalty area and held onto to him....100% red.

[Ollie the Optimist]

I just don't get how you can say that, he hauled him down in the penalty area and held onto to him....100% red.

if he would have 100% got to the ball first. he wouldnt have, therefore its not a clear goalscoring opportunity so not a red

[Niall_Quinn]

Replay shows the kompany sending off is fair enough.

[Özim]

its a penalty but not a red. dzecko wouldnt have got to the ball first, therefore it isnt denying a clear goalscoring opportunity given chensey would have got there first. however it is a penalty.

The pundits thought it was 100% red, so did most people...they even read the rules of the game....it's a 100% red unless you don't know the rules I'm afraid.

[GP]

if he would have 100% got to the ball first. he wouldnt have, therefore its not a clear goalscoring opportunity so not a red

Exactly right.

[Joker]

i have. chesney would have got there first. penalty yes, red card no,

Chesney would not have got there first, he wasn't even in the frame until after Dzeko's already been hauled down.