Baines has given consistent performance, perhaps but not at the Champions League level/Top 4 level that we are required to perform at. Baines gets a lot of good grace for his set piece ability and his attacking. Gibbs, like our defence in general has been fairly consistent for a season and a half now; is it a coincidence that we've not had a bad beating with him playing? I'd say no it's not and it's getting a bit tiresome that so many look to other clubs that have better performers, seemingly across the board from sides we routinely finish above.