I can't do a Tennis equivalent, but I can with boxing.
It's like somebody questioning Amir Khan's defence and chin just before facing Prescott. Khan hadn't faced any heavy hitters and once he did he was exposed and knocked out.
Some of the criticism about Wenger years ago may have been a bit OTT but a lot of truth in what was said back then. I still remember the backlash when I said Wenger was a poor tactician.
Really?....I always thought that was a given (that Wenger was at the very most basic tactically)
You could always get at Federer's back hand even back in 2006, and on a slow surface like Clay Nadal used to Muller Federer this way
(proved by the fact that Federer faced Nadal five times at Roland Garros including four finals and lost every time).
But there is a difference between pointing out someone's weaknesses and saying they are useless.
Wenger had many weaknesses that were evident in 2006, he dithered in the transfer market.....despite getting to the champions league final.....we had gone through a league season losing 11 games where he hadn't replaced Vieira and we were losing games 1-0 all over the shop for the next season or so because we literally had no supply up to our front line in many games.
But there was certainly no cause to sack him at that time.
Ashburton2006 was ridiculed because he only posted on here when we had bad results and came across as a WUM.