
Originally Posted by
Kano
Welbeck never scored that many in a season and let's face it, even if given that sort of run, would never get figures that high. There have been one season wonders before but I can't remember one pretty much being the top scorer in the league and then tailing off into nothing. The only one I can think of is Kevin Phillips and in the two seasons where Sunderland massively overachieved with two 7th place finishes, he got a very healthy 48 in 80 games.
I'm not sure the Eduardo comparison holds up too well. He'd at least had a few seasons scoring goals and playing in Europe and I tend to think we look back a bit favouarbly him at Arsenal in terms of what he achieved pre-injury, probably due to what happened to him. His stats were pretty middle of the road before the injury I think.
If we are looking at buying a player that can potentially be an improvement on Giroud straight away, then buying the leagues second highest scorer is a safer bet. Every transfer is a risk to a certain degree and the gamble we would have to take on Janssen immediately being better than Giroud is higher I think. Price doesn't really matter and shouldn't be a concern to us either. Otherwise you end up sounding like Wenger. And you don't want that surely Zim?