Chamack - the worst football player i have ever seen in my life

[LDG]

[Marc Overmars]

The formation excuse for Chamakh doesn't wash. If you're good enough you should be able showcase your ability regardless, I'm more inclined to sympathise with Bendtner who was alienated on the right, than Chamakh who is at least being played up top.

The guy has no spark about him and is on par with Heskey in terms of what he brings to the side.

[Olivier's xmas twist]

Like Bordeaux where he won the league and he had a great season both domestically and in Europe? He had the likes of Gourcuff supplying him then. Now its Benayoun Play him with RVP, let him have a run in the team and he'll be fine. The 4-5-1/4-3-3 has been a failure and its time to go back to basics.

Good season he miight have had don't mean he was ever world class, Last season he played with Nasri and Cesc one of the best Midfielders in the world and he still was not good.

it don't matter which midfilder you put him with he won't be good enough in this league. The french league is where he belongs and should have gone in the summer.

[IBK]

Worked hard last night, and provided a few decent knock downs, but didn't have the support. Needs to play two up, but with someone who can feed off him. But isn't up to the pace of English Football. His legs don't work quick enough.

Think he's a decent player, but not one good enough for the pace we play the game at.

Not his fault, and can't fault his effort either; But at a time where we need decent cover we need back up we can rely on, and if he can't provide, we need to be brutal.

This.

[Dog Toffee]

Zimm is also right about AW and everything else.

Zimm

No Zimm is only ever negative about everything, hence he is seen to turn out to be right when something goes wrong.


Oh and Chamakh is fucking terrible, its scary that if RvP gets injured we have him, Park (whos clearly not PL standard yet, but am willing to give time) and Fatshavin. Thats bad, we need a striker in Jan surely?

[Kano]

This.

seconded

[Master Splinter]

Afobe would have scored two hat-tricks last night.

But he's injured, of course.

[Özim]

No Zimm is only ever negative about everything, hence he is seen to turn out to be right when something goes wrong.


Oh and Chamakh is fucking terrible, its scary that if RvP gets injured we have him, Park (whos clearly not PL standard yet, but am willing to give time) and Fatshavin. Thats bad, we need a striker in Jan surely?

I'm afraid that's completely wrong, whilst there's hasn't been that much that I have liked about the club in recent years, RVP, Wilshere, Oxo, Ramsey amongst a handful of others I have praised and been happy with.

Chamakh was one player who I just didn't see as the answer for us, fact is we needed someone who could put the ball in the net and based on what I'd seen of him this guy liked to hang out outside the box and when he did score they were generally very simple chances that were harder to miss.

Noone agreed with me then and now people like you find other reasons as to why my opinion isn't valid, well done

[Niall_Quinn]

I'm afraid that's completely wrong, whilst there's hasn't been that much that I have liked about the club in recent years, RVP, Wilshere, Oxo, Ramsey amongst a handful of others I have praised and been happy with.

Chamakh was one player who I just didn't see as the answer for us, fact is we needed someone who could put the ball in the net and based on what I'd seen of him this guy liked to hang out outside the box and when he did score they were generally very simple chances that were harder to miss.

Noone agreed with me then and now people like you find other reasons as to why my opinion isn't valid, well done

It could be argued by some that I haven't been totally sold on Chamakh either.

[Fist of Lehmann]

It could be argued by some that I haven't been totally sold on Chamakh either.

The difference is that you were prepared to give him the benefit of 1 or 2 games before slagging him off. You don't even come close to the visionary genius of ItsGee.