I'm not rubbishing any notion, just offering up stats and concrete evidence that his perfomances over the past few seasons have not been inconsistent in the context of other members of our team and comparable players in PL.
Sure he's been anonymous, what do you expect? He's an emerging talent, he can't be a star everytime he plays.
Bottomline is his performances have been up there with our best performers for the past few seasons. Yes he isn't "World Class" but right now he offers more to our team than everybody bar Carzola.
Finally, you were the one that said Theo was replaceable but you have yet to offer up a player who could replace him who is within our budget etc?