If Adebayor were playing for us today, you'd be pulling your hair out over the missed chances and bad touches. Far from clinical. Just as bad as Theo and Giroud in that department. In fact, he was worse but played in a team that had games where we'd carve out chance after chance. But let's not forget that he also struggled when teams parked the bus and that's where we really needed a clinical striker and he wasn't it.
A few people rated Chamakh in his first season. That guy was worse than Niklas Bendtner.