
Enrique had won La Liga twice and done the Treble before getting sacked. Conte has won multiple titles with Juve and won a title with Chelsea. He's managed Italy! Yet you'd rank Tuchel as a teir one manager with only a domestic cup to his name above both of them?
With that sort of logical thinking, you could rank Brendan Rodgers and Arsene Wenger as top teir managers.
Zim was right to point out that fans on here were pulling the same hypothetical calculations for David Moyes until he finally landed a top job at Man Utd and was totally exposed. We all used to think the same about Wenger with the 'what could have been' scenarios if he had more money! It's only after seeing a consistent pattern of CL run failures and seeing that Wenger has a serious mental block in Europe that we realised that Wenger has a problem and it's not the personnel.
After two seasons with Dortmund, it is too short of a window to rank Tuchel with the guys that have actually won league titles and stronger records in Europe. Let's just wait and see what he does.